Shay Deeter
Shay Deeter is a real estate agent who prides herself on her professionalism, integrity, and local expertise in South Florida. She often showcases her favorite local establishments on her social media. Her clients describe her as trustworthy, resourceful, and a powerful negotiator. Shay is frequently praised for her ability to remain composed during high-pressure situations that can arise throughout real estate transactions, confidently guiding her clients to the closing table. This has earned her a reputation as a trusted consultant in the real estate community among both clients and peers.
Shay’s remarkable attentiveness and ability to connect with others help her understand and anticipate her clients’ needs. She possesses extensive knowledge of the Treasure Coast's diverse communities and the amenities they offer. Drawing on her background in the construction industry and her experience flipping homes, Shay brings a unique perspective that her clients appreciate and value when buying or selling their own homes.
In the first year of Shay's real estate career, she was honored as “Rookie of the Year.” She is also a distinguished Luxury Home Marketing Specialist with Guild™ recognition and a CELA certification. Shay gained ample transactional and negotiating experience while previously being a high producer on a top-performing team in Florida. She has worked with luxury buyers and sellers, investors, first-time home buyers, and renters. She also has a comprehensive understanding of the unique needs of buyers relocating from another state or country, having herself moved from Pennsylvania to Florida.
When Shay isn’t showing homes, she loves traveling the world, with her favorite destinations so far being Italy, Iceland, and Costa Rica. Shay is a foodie with a passion for cooking, loves fashion, and cherishes time spent with her family.
Office
300 W Indiantown Rd
Jupiter, FL 33458
Languages
- English
Testimonials
“Working with Shay was a great experience from start to finish. She was extremely professional and took the time to walk me through the entire selling process, which made everything stress-free. She created a strong listing, priced my home spot-on, and we were able to sell in just over 30 days. I’m very grateful for her expertise and would gladly recommend her.”
“Shay is a dream realtor! She got our house sold in 37 days at a very attractive price in a slow real estate market! Shay meet with us and listen to our concerns regarding selling our family home. She understood our home’s value, educated us on the current market and helped price our home competitively. She put together an extensive marketing plan which included excellent professional photography including drone shots, videos and lifestyle montages posted on social media, as well as did open houses and a broker open house. She’s an excellent communicator and negotiator. She has a vast network within the industry and strong relationships with other realtor and vendors. Don’t list your house without interviewing Shay! You won’t be disappointed!”
“Shay is an exceptional realtor! She went out of her way to accommodate my needs and timeline, and she constructed the perfect deal--one I thought might be impossible. She made sure every detail was handled with care and professionalism, and gave me complete confidence throughout the entire process. I highly recommend working with Shay for your real estate needs. She exceeded every expectation, and I will absolutely continue using her for all of my future real estate transactions.”
“Shay is an exceptional realtor! She went out of her way to accommodate my needs and timeline, and she constructed the perfect deal--one I thought might be impossible. She made sure every detail was handled with care and professionalism, and gave me complete confidence throughout the entire process. I highly recommend working with Shay for your real estate needs. She exceeded every expectation, and I will absolutely continue using her for all of my future real estate transactions.”
“Working with Shay was an amazing experience from start to finish. Her deep local knowledge truly set her apart — she knows the neighborhoods inside and out, from school districts to the best local spots. She guided me through every step of the process with professionalism, patience, and care. I always felt supported and informed, and she went above and beyond to make sure I found the perfect home. If you’re looking for someone who really understands the area and puts her clients first, Shay is the one to call!”
“Shay goes above and beyond to make sure you are happy. She does not make you feel rushed while viewing homes and provides suggestions or things one can do in unique spaces in a home. She kept in contact with us during the buying process, very knowledge and professional. I highly recommend her to anyone wanting to work with a dedicated realtor”
“Shay took care of my new home purchase 2 years ago and she’s still helping family members now as well. We love her service, professionalism and genuine care.”
“I spoke Shay Deeter a few years ago prior to my move to Florida. It took me over 2 years to relocate to Florida. Once I got here, I started looking for lots with Shay. After finding my perfect lot, I used Synergy Homes for my builder. I viewed other builders with Shay, but I liked a model that Synergy had and was able to change items in the floor plan that I wanted. Working with Shay was the best, she a terrific realtor, always on top of things, answered all my questions, and was always there to help me navigate the whole process. Of course, I will always recommend Shay to anyone looking for a realtor!”
“I met Shay over 2 years ago when I was looking to relocate to PSL, FL. It took a while but I'm finally here as of September '24. Shay found a perfect lot in a great location, and I settled on it in the beginning of January 2025. I choose Synergy Homes for my home builder. The slab was poured in February. The build went very quickly, and it was finished the end of June. I love working with Shay - she's the BEST, always on top of everything, responds very quickly to all my questions, and I'll recommend her to anyone looking for a great person and realtor!”
“I give her five stars and beyond! I have bought and sold using Shay and was totally satisfied on all three occasions. She makes you feel as if you are her most important client and goes above and beyond to make sure you are happy with your final decisions. She demonstrates this with expert communication , knowledge, professionalism and genuine concern for her clients. I highly recommend her to family, friends and to anyone wanting to work with the best realtor in the business!”
“Shay, It’s truly an amazing realtor agent to work with. At times, you may not want to hear what she have to say and selling the house with the price you think you want and the actual pricing of the home. I am so happy my husband and I took some time and took her suggestions to sell our two homes with her and purchase our new home. It’s very difficult to find a hard-working and honest Shay.”
“I met Shay about 2 years ago when I was looking to relocate to PSL, FL. It took a while but I'm finally here as of September '24. Shay found a lot, great location, and I settled on it in the beginning of January '25. I went to Synergy Homes with Shay and will have Synergy for my home builder. I love working with Shay - she's the best, always on top of everything, responds very quickly to all my questions, and I'll recommend her to anyone looking for a great person and realtor!”
